Sunday, September 23, 2012

How to Keep the Rules

We're back again looking at Jesus arguing with someone. And the topic is the Sabbath. It's sad to think that he had to spend so much time in conflict. But, I suppose that is to be expected. People can be very resistant to the truth.


Today's text is a little different from what we're used to when reading one of the Gospels. We're used to Jesus telling stories or performing miracles. We've listened in on several conversations that Jesus had with different people. But today's text is not going to be like that. It's going to be more like something from one of Paul's letters. You know how Paul can be. First point. Second point. Third point. And - Voila! - conclusion. But sometimes it's not exactly clear how he got to that conclusion. There are quiet assumptions in what Paul writes. You have to read him slowly and carefully. Today's text is something like that because Jesus isn't telling a story or having a conversation. He is presenting an argument. And the point of the argument sounds like something from Paul. It’s about how to correctly obey God’s Law. So, today’s sermon is going to be a little different from the others from John. Our text is John 7.14-24. Please listen as I read it.


The obvious issue here is the Sabbath. But don't focus just on that. In a text like this it's important to be aware of the bigger picture. The larger question is, 'What does keeping the Law of God look like?' Jesus fails at that, or so say the Jewish leaders who persist in attacking him. To them that's just an obvious fact. He breaks the Sabbath. He does not keep God's Law. And because of that they want to kill him. Jesus makes that plain. 'Why do you seek to kill me?' They respond by basically telling Jesus that he is nuts. 'You have a demon! Who is trying to kill you?' And yet, John has already written about what happened after Jesus healed a man on a Sabbath.

And this was why the Jews were persecuting Jesus, because he was doing these things on the Sabbath. But Jesus answered them, “My Father is working until now, and I am working.” This was why the Jews were seeking all the more to kill him, because not only was he breaking the Sabbath, but he was even calling God his own Father, making himself equal with God.

So, you see, Jesus isn't overstating the situation. They wanted to kill him. And one reason for that had to do with how he obeyed the Law of God. They wanted to kill him, and so, they did.

Now, Jesus had a few options on how to respond to their charge that he was breaking the Sabbath. He could have told them that they were misunderstanding the point of the Sabbath, that it had become anything but a day of rest because of all of their added rules. He does that elsewhere, but he doesn't do that here. Instead, Jesus attempts to reason with them, to apply logic to the debate. He tries to show them that they are not being consistent when they accuse him in the way that they do. Listen again to what he said.

Moses gave you circumcision (not that it is from Moses, but from the fathers), and you circumcise a man on the Sabbath. If on the Sabbath a man receives circumcision, so that the law of Moses may not be broken, are you angry with me because on the Sabbath I made a man's whole body well?

To get Jesus' point there’s one thing you have to know. As far as the Jewish community was concerned, circumcising someone was work. But they all knew that there isn't supposed to be any work done on a Sabbath. So, when they circumcise someone on a Sabbath what are they doing? They are breaking the Sabbath. That is, they are doing something defined as work. And that's what Jesus is pointing to. 'You break the Sabbath to do a man good by circumcising him. I break the Sabbath to do a man good by healing him. Why is it okay for you to break the Sabbath by working but it's not okay for me?' He's telling them that they are not being consistent.

Now, here’s what I want you to see. As he points to their inconsistency Jesus makes an assumption. Sometimes it's okay to work on a Sabbath. This is when it's important to remember that larger question: 'What does keeping the Law of God look like?' With that question in mind, this is what that assumption means. Sometimes it's okay to break the rules. Sometimes it's okay to disobey one of God's Laws.

Now, saying that is a really big deal. God's Law was - and is - the basis of the religion of the people of God. How many times do we read about the prophets saying, 'Be sure to obey God's Law. If you don't, it won't be pretty. God promised a curse on those who ignore his Law. Be sure to obey'? But here is Jesus saying that sometimes it's okay to break those Laws. And that's the first point that I want you to see. According to Jesus, sometimes it's okay to break God's Law. And proper Sabbath-keeping is just one example of that.

Now, it's time for my second point. And here I want to tweak what I just told you. In the long history of the Church there have been more than a few who have heard this sort of thing about breaking God's Law and have concluded that Jesus is a great role model for radical change. Jesus is all about tearing down the old ways and starting over again from scratch. He's the original revolutionary, or so they tell us. So, according to these folk, this is what Jesus is saying about things like the Sabbath: 'Mosaic laws? Who needs them? Let's dump them and start all over again.' But instead of talking about Mosaic Laws, these people point at whatever traditional structures are popular at their particular historical moment, and that's what they tear down. After all, that's what Jesus did, right?

Well, actually no. Listen again to what Jesus said.

If on the Sabbath a man receives circumcision, so that the law of Moses may not be broken...

Did you hear the 'so that'? Jesus is saying that a man is to receive circumcision on the Sabbath, that is, work is to be done and the Sabbath is to be violated, so that (ready?) 'the law of Moses may not be broken...' Jesus isn't tearing down the Law. No, he is working very hard to keep it, to make sure that it isn't broken. Jesus agrees that obeying the Law is important. And that's why he wants to do it right. So, he breaks one particular Law from God so that God's Law might not be broken.

This will make no sense unless you understand this important point: some of God's Laws are more important than other Laws of his. Where did I get that from? Well, I got it from Jesus.

Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you tithe mint and dill and cumin, and have neglected the weightier matters of the law: justice and mercy and faithfulness.

Now, be careful. Is the tithe important? Absolutely! It's one of God's Laws. But is it as important as justice and mercy and faithfulness? No. These are 'weightier'. These are more important. So, if there is ever a conflict between offering the tithe and pursuing justice it should be clear which wins out. The law of the tithe is violated so that the Law of God might not be broken; that is, so that the justice that God demands might be maintained. To be sure, the Sabbath is a day of rest. That is God's Law. Jesus violates the Sabbath so that he can make sure that the more important parts of the Law are not neglected. It is because of his desire to honor the Law that he healed the man on the Sabbath. He broke the Sabbath in order to keep God's Law.

So, you see, obeying God's Laws really is important. Jesus was eager to do that. But, as we see here, sometimes obeying God's Laws will require you to break one of them. Jesus breaks God's Laws about the Sabbath so that he can keep other, more important Laws from God.

So, let me summarize what I’ve said thus far.

According to Jesus, sometimes it's okay to break one of God's Laws.
But, according to Jesus, the only time it's okay to break one of God's Laws is so that you can keep another, more important Law of God.

And this goes a long way to answering our question, 'What does keeping the Law of God look like?'

Now for part two of the sermon. This is where I show how this makes a difference in how you live. Let me explain what I’m going to do here. The question that the sermon has been dealing with is, ‘What does keeping the Law of God look like?' Before I talk about why this question is really important today, there are two other areas that I feel I need to deal with. They have to do with motive and method. Why should you obey God’s Law and how do you do that? Let’s consider those now.

Let’s start with this. Obeying God's Law is still important. That is a point that needs to be made these days. It explains why we have the 'Reading of God's Law' as part of our worship every week. And I hope that you notice that those readings come from both the Old Testament and the New Testament. God still has Laws for us. And obeying them is still important.

And that leads to the question of motive. Why is obeying God's Law so important? Here’s one possible answer. Obedience in these things is important because that will result in God liking you. Or to flip that around, not obeying these things will result in God not liking you, at least not as much as he might. But let's examine that. Is that the Gospel? Does the Gospel teach that God will love you and treat you well but only if you obey? Is that the Gospel? If it is, then we should be honest and summarize it something like this. The Gospel is the good news that because of Jesus God loves sinners - except when they sin. If that is the Gospel, then we are all done for. But, that’s not the Gospel. And thanks be to God for that.

But why, then, is obeying God's Law so important? It's a fact that God expects obedience. It’s closer to the truth to say that he demands obedience. But please note that the obedience that he calls for is perfect obedience. Without perfect obedience life becomes hell. And that perfection is not just about what you do. It's also about why you do it. So, it's both behavior (the what) and attitude (the why). It's about what happens in the body (how you act) and what happens in the soul (why you act). God demands perfect obedience, body and soul. And that is something that we cannot do - not even close. But Jesus did that. He obeyed the Law perfectly, in body and soul. And the Gospel says that his perfect obedience has been given to you. Because of Jesus' perfect obedience given to you, the Father declares that you have already obeyed all of the Law - perfectly. And so, because of what Jesus has done, the Father likes you. Because of Jesus, he will always like you, and he will always do good to you. Always. Even when you sin. That's the Gospel. That's what believing in Jesus brings.

But we still haven't answered that question. If God's Law is not a condition for us to satisfy so that we can be loved, why is it important? Why do we need to bother with obeying it? It helps to remember that the Law is not an arbitrary list of right and wrong. It's the Father's description of a life that is good for us. It's all about how to live well. But it's not only that. It's also a description of a life that pleases him. So, our working to obey God's Law is, on the one hand, our pursuit of a really good life, and, on the other hand, it's an act of love in response to the Father's love. We obey him because we love him. Now, we do a really bad job of obeying him - really bad. (Remember the what and the why of perfect obedience.) But that's okay. The Father still gladly accepts it as our gift of love. It's like the little kid's drawing that he proudly gives to his mom. Is it a tree? Or maybe a house? Nobody knows. But it doesn't matter because to his mom it's beautiful. That's our attempts at obedience as a gift to the Father - not very good but cherished by the Father as beautiful.

Okay, so obeying God's Law is still important. And we've answered the motivation question, 'Why obey God's Law?' Now, for the method question. 'How do we do this?'

Keeping God's Law is not a matter of sorting through some chart that will tell you, 'In situation 'A', always apply rule 17. In situation 'B' you should always apply rule 31.' Life might be simpler that way. All you have to do is have that chart with you and follow the rules. It might be simpler, but it's wrong. It's evil. If that’s how we should live, then, instead of healing that lame man, Jesus should have walked right passed him. After all, it was a Sabbath and the rules for Sabbath keeping are clear. Don't work! But that's just wrong. It’s evil because it’s heartless.

There will be times when you will need to break a Law so that you can keep the Law. But when do you do that? When is it right to break one of God's Laws? To answer that you will need the aid of the Spirit. He is the one who gives the ability to see what's really going on in a situation. He's the one who answers the Christian's prayer, 'Lord, what do I do now? What does obedience look like in this situation?' The Spirit will use the Bible. That's where you'll find God's Laws. And that's also where you'll find examples of times when the saints broke one of God's Laws so that they could obey him. Study the Law, study the examples and pray. The Spirit will guide. But understand that the Spirit also uses the other people in this room to give each of you the guidance that you need. Nobody knows enough Bible for this. And nobody has experienced enough life to understand all the different situations that come down the pike. The Spirit uses the Word and he uses the saints. And as you will find, if you haven't already, there are things you do not know about the Bible and about life, things that you will need to learn. So, you're going to get it wrong from time to time. But that's okay. The Father still sees Jesus' perfection in you. His love for you never wavers.  

Now we’re ready for my last thought. This is about one particular area where all of this becomes very important. At a recent Bible study, the name of Dietrich Bonhoeffer came up. He was a faithful Christian and pastor. He was executed by the Nazis because he was part of a plot to assassinate the tyrant of Germany, Adolf Hitler. To say that more bluntly, he planned to murder someone. Isn't there a Law from God about murder? Was Bonhoeffer right to want to do that? Was he right to break one of God’s Laws? This is not as theoretical a question as it may seem. I am not a prophet so I can't predict the future. But I think that it is safe to say that the days are evil, and they are getting worse. I think that it is safe to say that, unless God sends revival, American culture will slowly but surely degenerate into a very dark place. What leavening influence the Gospel may have had in the past, it no longer does. That influence is almost completely gone in large sections of our country. In saying this I don't necessarily mean that we will face complete social disintegration, chaos in the streets and all of that. I just mean that we will be surrounded by a more completely pagan way of living. Ancient Greece, in its heyday, was not a group of people at each other's throats just trying to survive. It was, in many ways, a very well-ordered society. But there was no Gospel there. Life was built on something else. And that's why it was an evil place. The days are coming when the remaining American Christians - your children and grandchildren - will need to be wise about when to keep one of God's Laws and when not to, so that God's Law might not be broken. It might even be safe to say that the beginning of those days has already dawned.

The need of the day is for wise disciples who know how to live well in a dark situation. They keep God's Law, sometimes by breaking one of them. But they do this in the power of the Spirit and because they love the Father. That’s the need and that’s what we are to work toward, to pray about, for ourselves and especially for our children.